Following Town Meeting budget failure, Sunapee Selectboard mulls cuts

By CHRISTINA DOLAN

Valley News Staff Writer

Published: 03-26-2025 4:16 PM

Modified: 05-27-2025 10:31 AM


SUNAPEE — After voters rejected a proposed town budget earlier this month, officials are scrambling to make the nearly $800,000 in cuts required to operate under a default budget.

“It’s going to be very, very, very difficult,” Selectboard Chairwoman Suzanne Gottling said by phone Monday. “We’re going to try to do the fairest and least disruptive things that we can do, but I don’t see how we can’t have disruptions.”

Voters at Town Meeting rejected the proposed $11.03 million budget, 516-494, making Sunapee the only Upper Valley town to reject its budget this year.

Excluding all other warrant articles, had voters approved the proposed budget it would have resulted in an estimated municipal tax rate of about $2.51 per $1,000 of property value, a 3% increase over the prior year.

The Selectboard, according to state statute RSA 40:13, may either accept the default budget, which is the previous year’s operating budget, or hold a special meeting to put a revised budget before voters.

Voters approved a town operating budget of $10.1 million last March.

Gottling, a former state representative for Sullivan County’s Second District, does not think that the board has an appetite for going back to voters a second time. At its March 17 meeting, the Selectboard discussed the possibility but did not make a decision.

“We have to go full steam ahead on living with the default budget, because even with an election, there could be a nay vote,” she said.

Article continues after...

Yesterday's Most Read Articles

Vermont Supreme Court greenlights Hartland farm store project
Windsor County deputy on leave after assault allegation
‘He died loving you’ — Jesse Sullivan sentenced in murder of half-brother Zackary
Kenyon: Dartmouth retaliates against Black alumni group for questioning college’s protest narrative
Over Easy: If I can dream
Sandra Oh tells Dartmouth graduates to ‘go on resisting’ and ‘always make the time to dance it out’

The board has called a special meeting for Monday to discuss the budget and the possibility of a second vote on a revised budget.

“I think there will be a decision one way or another” at that meeting, Gottling said of the possible second vote.

Displeasure with the increased tax rate, objections to wage increases for town employees, and the proposed creation of more than a million dollars in capital reserve funds contributed to the “no” votes, according to some residents who opposed the proposed budget and the idea of a second vote.

“Sunapee has been waging war on the taxpayers of this town, and it has to stop,” resident Chris Whitehouse said by phone Monday. “We have a struggling middle class here. This is a poor tax.”

More than 16% of Sunapee’s roughly 3,200 residen ts live in poverty, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. In Sullivan County, the overall rate of poverty is 11%.

The town’s proximity to Lake Sunapee and Mt. Sunapee contributes to a thriving tourist economy and property tax base.

Resident Lisa Hoekstra, who also opposed the proposed budget, said that the Selectboard and town manager have “pandered to the wealthy,” rather than to Sunapee’s full-time residents.

“They are not for the common man,” she said by phone Monday.

Gottling said on Wednesday that “no one on the Board doubts that there are townspeople struggling to make ends meet.”

That the board would consider a second vote also doesn’t sit well with Whitehouse or Hoekstra.

“It’s not illegal,” Whitehouse said, “but it does seem a little bit on the shady side.”

Hoekstra thinks that a second vote would further damage trust and confidence in town leadership that, she said, is already shaky.

“The culture of our government is not fully transparent or honest,” she said. “To try to hit a redo is really disrespectful to the people who voted.”

Town Manager Shannon Martinez did not return requests for comment by deadline.

In a video recording of the March 17 Selectboard meeting, Martinez said that the proposed budget that went before voters at Town Meeting was “bare bones” and that “there is no way to maintain the level of service we have now” under a default budget.

“There are services that are going to go away” she said.

Neither the Selectboard nor the town manager discussed specific cuts at the March 17 meeting.

The Selectboard will hold a special meeting on Monday, March 31 at 6:30 p.m. in the town office meeting room at 23 Edgemont Road in Sunapee to discuss the budget process.

Christina Dolan can be reached at cdolan@vnews.com or 603-727-3208.

CORRECTION: Excluding all other warrant articles, the proposed budget Sunapee voters rejected at Town Meeting would have resulted in an estimated municipal tax rate of $2.51 per $1,000 of property value, a 3% increase over the rate for the prior year. A previous version of this story incorrectly stated the estimated increase to the tax rate the proposed budget would have caused.