Commentary: ‘It’s Always Sunny’ Has Become TV’s Sharpest Political Comedy

  • Kaitlin Olson as Dee, Rob McElhenney as Mac, Danny DeVito as Frank and Charlie Day as Charlie on “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia.” MUST CREDIT: Patrick McElhenney, FX

The Washington Post
Thursday, September 27, 2018

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia has never exactly shied away from political topics. Early episodes about the group of frenemies who own a bar in a Philly back alley included plot lines with titles such as “The Gang Solves the North Korea Crisis” and “The Gang Goes Jihad.”

These episodes weren’t exactly in-depth dissections of foreign policy difficulties so much as odd situations that allowed our increasingly grotesque protagonists to be awful in new and terrible ways. But there was always a blunt truth hiding around the edges of the show.

Consider the Season Two episode “The Gang Runs for Office.” Yes, the plot — which sees Dennis (Glenn Howerton) run for local office so he and his friends Charlie (Charlie Day), Mac (Rob McElhenney), Dee (Kaitlin Olson), and Frank (Danny DeVito) can earn income by soliciting bribes — is farcical. But it gets at the deeper reality of how some people see government: corrupt, inefficient, a game rigged against them.

Similarly, Frank’s comments about Hillary Clinton, whom he calls “awful” because she “hates freedom,” should have served as a stark warning for Democrats in 2016. Frank may not be the most sympathetic character in the world — that whole exchange is intended to make him look like a misogynistic jerk — but he’s right about how Clinton appeared to many voters. Regardless of whether or not Clinton actually “hates freedom” (Which freedoms? Hates how?), the perception that she did was baked into the cake as far back as 2006.

Now, in the sitcom’s 13th season, writers have kicked it up a notch and given episodes a running theme: gender politics. But they have done so in a manner that is rarely didactic and often immensely funny, weaving insights about the ridiculous world in which we live into It’s Always Sunny’s ridiculous characters.

Look at the season premiere, during which it seemed as if resident psychopath Dennis might be replaced by Cindy (Mindy Kaling). Cindy dreams up a genius effort to drive sales by ginning up outrage against a neighboring bar and selling a wine labeled “Liberal Tears.” There’s another meta-story at work, however, about a woman of color replacing an emotionally abusive white guy in the workplace and the fact that the group, including its women, chooses to side with the emotionally abusive white guy by episode’s end.

The season’s second episode, during which the friends participate in an “escape room,” was funny for all the reasons It’s Always Sunny tends to be funny: It was about five people who not-so-secretly hate each other forming factions in order to screw the others over. But if you were paying attention to certain clues (talk about the roles of men and women; discussions of posture and animals and eye contact), you might think the show was subtly mocking Jordan Peterson and his adherents for suggesting that life consists of a series of simple tricks one must master to live well.

I tend to think of Peterson’s advice as banal rather than existentially threatening. (Standing up straight and keeping your room clean aren’t revolutionary concepts.) But its very banality makes it ripe for humor. And, assuming the jibes were intentional, Always Sunny writer Megan Ganz played it well by keeping the criticism sotto voce instead of turning the episode into a diatribe.

The most recent episode of It’s Always Sunny, which mocked the epidemic of gender-swapped reboots, was less successful than its predecessors because it felt like a diatribe. “The Gang Beats Boggs: Ladies Reboot” is, as it sounds, a (nearly) ladies-only reboot of Season 10 premiere “The Gang Beats Boggs.” But with more gross-out humor! The bit didn’t quite work for me, if only because the characters kept talking about the general silliness of rebooting properties with women in the lead roles. Or perhaps this was another meta-joke, aimed at the people constantly complaining about the uselessness of such productions.

Alongside Comedy Central’s South Park, which has deftly highlighted the increasing insanity of The Discourse in recent years, It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia is walking a tightrope between maintaining its comedic bona fides and actually saying something interesting. And it is managing to do so without resorting to the cheap clapter preferred by political talk shows in the mold of The Daily Show.

Sonny Bunch is the executive editor of, and film critic for, the Washington Free Beacon.